Print edition purchases must be purchased directly from ArtScroll or Each translation page faces Gemara page of the classic Vilna Shas; 9″ x. Print edition purchases must be purchased directly from ArtScroll or Each translation page faces Gemara page of the classic Vilna Shas; 7″ x. 7 Results Published By: ArtScroll Mesorah Publications. Release Date: 12/20/ Format : Hardcover. List Price: $2, Your Price: $2, Discount.
|Published (Last):||14 February 2005|
|PDF File Size:||9.60 Mb|
|ePub File Size:||16.91 Mb|
|Price:||Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]|
November 13, 9: November 12, 5: November 11, 7: To do this research even for an accomplished Talmid chacham would take many hours. Why do you define ameilus as going deep in a gemara and breaking your head? So remember that any translation is a tool, and usually a valuable tool, but it is only a tool. whas
How would leaving out every single thought on a subject, as you suggest, be an issue of dishonesty??? Go ahead and use Artscroll and dont be shy about it.
Every word of the text appears, vowelized and translated Each phrase is explained so that the reader understands the reasoning and flow Each question, answer, proof and rebuttal is introduced so that the reader will know where the Gemara is taking him Notes expand on the explanation of the Gemara’s points, and explain unfamiliar ideas without interrupting the flow of the text Detailed diagrams Introductions to the entire tractate and to each topic, wherever necessary Glossary explains key expressions in each tractate Rashi headings in bold type Each translation page faces Gemara page of the classic Vilna Shas 7″ x 10″ page size Acid-free paper Magnificent specially sculpted cover Reinforced deluxe library binding for long use Ribbon-marker The total linear measurement for this set is What do Artscroll and GPS have in common??
The irony of all this is that the added clarifications put into Artscroll shas are written in there artcroll experts who study with untranslated shas.
For this reason I learn in a regular Gemara and have an Artscroll on the side. Not at all,I know ppl shaw could use artscroll but instead make fun of it. Precisely the working person should not be using AS.
Schottenstein Talmud Sets
Let the Talmud open your eyes to the wonders of the Torah. Viewing 50 posts – 1 through 50 of 59 total. In my humble opinion, I would add, if you were fortunate to have received a Yeshiva education, you might want to get both an Oz ViHadar to learn from and an Artscroll to refer to as needed, particularly for perakim with lots of aggadita and other heretofore unfamiliar concepts.
November 10, Open the Schottenstein Edition and step into a “study hall wrtscroll walls. I prefer learning in a regular gemara rather than the Gemara side of the Artscroll.
Powered by Duvys Media. Yes Art Scroll is a crutch -but some people need crutches to walk. When my daughter got engaged, i approached her choson. Simchas Hatorah and remembering the Torah can only come from your ameilus without any extra help.
Sha Mesorah Publications Published: Home Schottenstein Talmud Sets.
The reason why people are against it is that sometimes, people use it as a crutch. November 13, 3: This bothers me because I want to remember the lashon of the Gemara and the tzuras hadaf.
Topic: artscroll shas | Yeshiva World News
If you only read the English words, maybe. Then you see Bochurim learning with artscrlll they will never know how to learn if its spoon fed ameilus is the only way. The gemara is written in a artscrll specific way, and if somebody uses an Artscroll before he knows how the gemara is written, it will be much harder for him to pick it up than if he spent the same amount of time and covered less ground learning out of a regular gemara.
Yungerman — Ameilus means to toil. I find that when I use Artscroll I have the whole set I am just reading the words and dont stop to think if I understand it.
November 11, 6: Why would Rashi write a phrase by phrase commentary simplifying the gemara so much? November 10, 5: These ppl artscrolll use and know a lot of Torah.
Log into your account.